But looking at the larger picture, this whole misjudgement has done some damage to Carney's leadership.
I thought one comment my son made today was perceptive:
It took years before Obama really understood how naive this was, that Repubs saw him as just another Dem politician.
Likewise, Carney also has to avoid thinking of himself as someone to whom the usual rules of politics do not apply.
Carney may not realize quite yet the extent to which Canadians, particularly progressive Canadians, have given him the benefit of the doubt over the last six months - because he was so much better than Poilievre and Singh was hopeless anyway, and we were all terribly afraid of Trump. We dearly wanted Carney to be that Big Daddy that Canada needed to save us. Carney is smart and brilliantly educated and had a stellar career; he has a great sense of humour and he was born in the west and he played hockey; he works harder than everyone else, and he knows and is respected by people around the world.
But this doesn't mean that Canadian conservatives (small-c or large-C) will respect him or work with him. It doesn't mean the progressive left will give him a pass when he takes a corporatist approach to development. It doesn't mean that Indigenous leaders will allow their hard-won authority to be threatened. And it doesn't mean that Carney will never miscalculate or make a mistake.
Carney cancels invite for Project 2025 mastermind, wants fascist takeover of Canada to be more of a surprise
— The Beaverton (@thebeaverton.com) September 4, 2025 at 2:32 PM
[image or embed]















