This is the way the Han Dong smear ends: not with a bang, but a whimper

 

The accusations against Han Dong are falling apart. 

Watch everyone nodding along as the translation error story was reported on Sunday:

Boom. Rob Benzie’s comments on @ctvqp this morning regarding recent media coverage of the Chinese foreign interference story: pic.twitter.com/z2EGS17Vi4

— Greg MacEachern (@gmacofglebe) March 26, 2023

Scrimshaw notes that Global didn't even cover the story themselves in their weekend show:

So, Global didn’t repeat their accusation about Han Dong on The West Block this morning? They broke the political story of the week and didn’t cover it on their own show?

That’s very odd

— Evan Scrimshaw (@EScrimshaw) March 26, 2023

The tide is going back out. It's fucking hilarious to watch pundits, competing media and conservatives alike begin to back down on Han Dong because of reckless reporting by Global News.

— Raoul Duke's Salt Shaker (@RodKahx) March 26, 2023

Today's Random Stuff: Horses, Dogs. and Turning Points

First, here is an amazing photo "Slam on the Brakes" from The Atlantic. It is © Steven Zhou and was taken in Ontario in August 2022. It won the 2023 Sony World Photography Award, in the Motion category. The Atlantic writes "Barrel racing is a competition where cowgirls ride quickly around barrels; the one that does this in the shortest time wins. Every time a horse reaches a barrel it needs to brake sharply, turn around the barrel and then race to the next one." 

Next, some other animal crackers:

Pretty good frens pic.twitter.com/8hNw7nH0qj

— Madeyousmile (@Thund3rB0lt) March 18, 2023

Dalton, the storytelling dragon, has these puppies mesmerized
(jukin media) pic.twitter.com/GAtD30XyzR

— theworldofdog (@theworldofdog) March 24, 2023

Today's News: Dark Brandon comes to Ottawa

Dark Brandon came to Canada today. 

It was very funny, really -- you see, our Conservatives watch too much Fox News, so they were all thinking that the Biden they would meet in Ottawa today is the weak and stumbling Joe that Fox News has created. 

But what Canada met was the "Dark Brandon" Joe, the guy who won't put up with any right-wing malarkey, and who can dish it out faster than they can take it. 

He called Poilievre and the Conservatives out on their disrespect for women, and they couldn't do anything but take it. 

Loved POTUS for that. We have an abusive, disrespectful opposition led by Pierre Poilievre who is far too cozy with the alt-right here. His only expertise is as a finger-pointing blameologist who blames PM Trudeau for causing inflation, & a host of other idiocies. #cdnpoli https://t.co/LqCA4Matpw

— Elke Babiuk (@ElkeBabiuk) March 24, 2023

Today's News: the Han Dong accusations

Today's biggest story was the Han Dong accusations. This is what he said yesterday to Parliament:

Han Dong informs the House that he will now sit as an independent MP after Global News reported, citing unnamed sources, he secretly advised a Chinese diplomat in 2021 to delay freeing Michael Spavor and Michael Kovrig. "What has been reported is false and I will defend myself." pic.twitter.com/kSX8rAbWCJ

— Power & Politics (@PnPCBC) March 23, 2023

Tonight, I see on Twitter this might all be just a stupid error in translation:

If this is true, and he told the Chinese consul to release the two Michaels immediately, and there was a mixup along the line, that would be unfortunate. I don't know if it is true.

— Stephen Maher (@stphnmaher) March 24, 2023

In other words some low level CSIS analyst read a poorly translated transcript and since nothing was done to arrest Dong, took it upon themselves to try and out him to media. I hope this bankrupts Global, there’s a reason Globe didn’t run the story.

— Eric O'Toole (@Eric_OTooleMP) March 24, 2023

Between the Globe not reporting the allegations, the PMO asking for the transcripts and deciding there’s no “actionable evidence”, this rumour, and Dong suing … this is a *disaster* for them

— Evan Scrimshaw (@EScrimshaw) March 24, 2023

This would also explain why it made no sense that releasing the Two Michaels would help the CPC, another part of Global’s story that makes no sense

— Evan Scrimshaw (@EScrimshaw) March 24, 2023

100%. The mistranslation explanation does really seem to make sense and fits much better with the overall story. #Handong #CDNpoli

— Matt Hopkins (@RealMattHopkins) March 24, 2023

Could it really be this simple? 

If so, then CSIS and Global News owe Canada an enormous apology. 

Twenty years ago

...Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold;

Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world,

The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere

The ceremony of innocence is drowned;

The best lack all conviction, while the worst

Are full of passionate intensity...

And what rough beast, its hour come round at last,

Slouches towards Bethlehem to be born?

I was appalled when the United States invaded Iraq in 2003 -- they were without UN Security Council support, without Canada or Mexico or France or Germany or most of the other countries of the world, who refused to support so-called "preventive" war.

America had lost their minds after 9/11 and too many of them seemed to think invading Iraq was the only way to show the Middle East that America was really the boss of the world. 

A million people died because of that terrible decision. 

And the only ones who appear to be ashamed about it today are the people who said it was immoral and a mistake in the first place. 

Thank heavens for the accident of history that kept Canada out of it - luckily, Chretien was getting ready to retire so he no longer cared about the politics of America or whether Britain thought he was cowardly. Chretien knew that regime-change was not a legitimate reason to start a war, and he said so, and he wanted to prevent pointless sacrifice of Canadian lives. 

Canada has never really thanked him enough for doing that, not the way we should have.

20 years ago this week, Jean Chretien’s government boldly said NO to George W. Bush’s illegal war in Iraq.

Chrétien said NO amid very strong support for the war among the 🇨🇦 business community, media + much of the public in English Canada. Not to mention the Official Opposition… https://t.co/YknenRMVor

— Andrew Perez (He/Him) (@andrewaperez) March 20, 2023

Notwithstanding the leader of the opposition, Stephen Harper embarrassing himself and Canada by apologizing for our decision to stay out of Iraq, on Fox News.

— NS Dave (@dave1oakns) March 19, 2023

I recall that support fell from initial strong support (70/30) to roughly reverse when decision to not join was made. Retrospectively hugely the right call https://t.co/Wo8EBoTq8l

— Frank Graves (@VoiceOfFranky) March 19, 2023

Today's News: Saskatchewan has created another cat party

A new provincial political party recently formed here, calling themselves the Sask United Party, which intends to out-conservative the existing Saskatchewan Party. 

Basically, I think its just another Cat party trying to pretend to be mice (see above for a video about Tommy Douglas' "Mouseland" analogy)

If the anti-immigrant, anti-science right-wing Conservative option is central are they saying Moe is a leftist commie or something? https://t.co/PaTiQuNUAh pic.twitter.com/d1PZKCWuBC

— M 🇺🇦 (@habpipes) March 2, 2023

But, maybe rural places are this angry. And if SK United can win four or five seats, then they're real players. If it can't, it is a blip and will have no permanent presence.

— Charles Smith (@ProfSmithSask) March 3, 2023

Very funny that a conservative splinter party is calling themselves Sask United. Especially since the NDP has only really been successful there when there have been two centre-right parties splitting the vote.

Mouseland lives! https://t.co/VvkGzEK7I8

— Justin Leifso (@JustinLeifso) March 3, 2023

I also wonder if the Sask United Party is basically just another reflection of the urban-rural divide, which here in Saskatchewan has now become an abyss. Now, Saskatchewan is hardly Canada's urban hell-hole but even here, we get fear and resentment of our cities, as well as a certain amount of fetishization of rural life.

Today's News: Temper Tantrums

Here's how I see it: 

First of all, Canadian voters haven't turfed Trudeau in three elections and chances are they won't in the 2025 either. 

The opinion polls are back and forth a bit - and who knows now what might be an issue in BC and Quebec and the Maritimes in two years - but the Golden Horseshoe is basically still Liberal territory and likely to remain so.  The CPC and the small-c conservative media in Canada know this. 

So they thought maybe they could find some big scandal or controversy that would force Trudeau to resign. But its been seven years now and nothing has worked - not JWR and SNC-Lavalin, not the WE Charity, not the Convoy, not the Emergencies Act, not the Rouleau report. The smaller stuff they keep trashing at him is just silly (remember the Indian outfits? the family beach walk in Tofino? the blackface 20 years ago? the Star Wars socks?) 

So finally, they started thinking that maybe China China China could do it. 

But today they realized that ain't gonna happen. China China China is a problem for Elections Canada, CSIS, RCMP and Canadian political parties (both Liberal and Conservative) but the David Johnston report, whenever it comes out, likely won't tarnish Trudeau personally.

Cue today's temper tantrums. They really went crazy:

The former Governor General himself is now being accused of treason by journalists. My goodness. pic.twitter.com/13o10zFYs0

— Gerald Butts (@gmbutts) March 17, 2023

Today's News: David Johnston to the rescue

 

I do keep wondering what, exactly, this China scandal is all about:

Seriously. Watching journalists in Canada is like watching 7 year olds playing soccer. Just a gaggle of kids chasing the ball. No strategy or plan. Only focused on one ball while the world burns around them.

— Neil Before Zod™ (@WaytowichNeil) March 15, 2023

🧵

The most interesting thing about the China scandal that has Canadian media in a feeding frenzy is that we know exactly nothing about it. It's a scandal because they say it is, not because anything scandalous has been revealed.

My $0.02 about the media-driven "scandal". 1/ pic.twitter.com/0bJDVZSFmO

— Rambod Behboodi (@GenevaTradeLaw) March 4, 2023

Now former governor general David Johnston is going to investigate and that's good -- maybe he can tell the rest of us exactly what is going on here, and whether a public inquiry is really the only way to sort it out.

Former CSIS director Richard Fadden, who also served as national-security adviser to Mr. Trudeau and former PM Stephen Harper.... “I think [David Johnston] is probably the only person in 🇨🇦 that would add sufficient credibility to the special rapporteur process....” @globeandmail

— Judy Gombita (@jgombita) March 16, 2023

But I think Poilievre already realizes Johnston's appointment will move the story off the front pages and there aren't going to be any "gotcha" revelations about Trudeau. So now he's trying his very best to discredit Johnston - and the CPC Flying Monkeys are desperately pushing to kibosh the appointment quick. Or likely they think it would be just as useful to see if they can discredit in advance any Johnston recommendations against a public inquiry.

whatever one's opinion of David Johnston being named a Special Rapporteur, "Beijing-funded Trudeau foundation" is a crass, ignorant comment

or, as we like to say, just another tweet from Pierre Poilievre https://t.co/EsskLWHul7

— Steve Ricketts (@SteveRickettsSP) March 16, 2023

Today's Random Stuff: Cats and Pigs and Politics

Its the weekend, so here we go with some random stuff from the lighter side. 

BBC News posted an very odd tweet about how the pandemic hadn't really affected anyone's mental health - and the internet immediately went nuts:

I built my cat a mech suit out of cardboard. https://t.co/UKkfBQlsVm pic.twitter.com/6Z5rgEnDZf

— Jesse McLaren (@McJesse) March 11, 2023

I made my cat a Viking ship and she kinda liked it pic.twitter.com/0BtqBGvoPL

— corndog (@jay_veaux) March 12, 2023

The cat army grows. pic.twitter.com/y5t1aBLqNA

— Teapot (@Clay_Teapot) March 11, 2023

Recreated them BADLY, with items sourced from the basement pic.twitter.com/Hhh2dArTH6

— DejaBlu (@KidKnapt) March 11, 2023

pic.twitter.com/q4XbtF9Sbw

— HawksNest1010 (@jay_hohl) March 9, 2023

Next, here's a pig blowing bubbles and its just so righteous:

https://www.tumblr.com/slitherpunk/710989148508553216/i-liked-that-video-of-a-pig-blowing-bubbles-but-i

Today's News: Outstanding Support for Trans Rights

I thought this was outstanding:

And with a disturbing rise in anti-transgender hate here in Canada and around the world recently, I want to be very clear about one more thing: Trans women are women. We will always stand up to this hate – whenever and wherever it occurs.

— Justin Trudeau (@JustinTrudeau) March 8, 2023

Because we don't get to choose the battle, we only get to choose our side. When people whose rights are under attack need us to stand up and be counted, then we all have to do that, just as Trudeau did. 

Of course he got criticized for it from the usual suspects - and he knew he would be - but he did it anyway.

Saskatoon City Council also stepped up yesterday:

Well done, Saskatoon city council! They handled this very well, I would say, and made it perfectly clear that trans people are a valued segment of society. 👏🏼 https://t.co/mIaTIE72tN

— FuzzyWuzzy💤 (@FuzzyWuzzyTO) March 9, 2023

Saskatoon's real freedom fighters showed up today and it was a beautiful thing to witness. #TransWomenAreWomen #TransRightsAreHumanRights https://t.co/CHUlTkkOdk

— Kyle Anderson (@DrKyle) March 8, 2023

Today's Random Stuff -- dogs, frogs, and physics

Dogs, bruh!

Great, now I have to go buy twice as many tennis balls. https://t.co/PMJnXwp8lJ

— Gerggers (@gerggers) February 23, 2023

this dog is friends with a crow and it's like a real life pixar movie
(jukin media) pic.twitter.com/A3pKDJOb9i

— theworldofdog (@theworldofdog) February 22, 2023

That Wascally Wabbit pic.twitter.com/SyuTkIDV1M

— Madeyousmile (@Thund3rB0lt) February 26, 2023

Duck and Dog Wrestle Playfully in Snow

Look how they play! 🙂

💌Follow for the most inspirational stories of hope, love, tradition, family and art. pic.twitter.com/1EaBIWBH4v

— Funniest Family Moments (@Funniest_Family) February 27, 2023

As seen on George Takai's substack:

Allow me to introduce you to the most ridiculous yet amazing thing you will see this week. pic.twitter.com/MHlGmz9Ph2

— fragrance and foolishness (@Brieyonce) February 27, 2023

Today's News: "Being Woke" = "Being Kind"

My husband and I were talking tonight and he asked "Exactly what is 'Woke' anyway?" 

Hmm, good question.  Coincidentally, I have been reading some stuff just today about it, and here it is. 

First, a few cartoons I found about how crazy the anti-woke MAGA is getting:

But defining Woke isn't difficult -- here's a succinct tweet from Bob Rae that describes the definition pretty well:

Another word for “woke” is “kindness”

— Bob Rae (@BobRae48) March 3, 2023

Today's Scene: An Inquiry If Necessary, but Not Necessarily An Inquiry

A batch of very good substacks this week. 

When it comes to the news of the day, the conclusion of the Canadian columnists I read is this: 

1. If China interfered in Canadian elections and the Liberals let them, then there needs to be an investigation and Trudeau would likely need to resign. 

2.  But the CSIS leaks so far seem to show just normal political activity by Chinese-Canadian Liberal supporters, whose political involvement should be applauded, not targeted.

3. So we should have an inquiry if necessary, but not necessarily an inquiry 

The commentary this week is too extensive to quote, but see Evan Scrimshaw here Foreign Interference and CSIS Leaks, and Dale Smith here Roundup: A smear to precede the report, and The Line here Emergency Dispatch: The China File, and Paul Wells here Things to do in Ottawa when you're not calling an inquiry into Chinese election interference 

For myself, I would add this point

4 Conservatives will lose the plot if they keep on trying to turn the China questions into just another partisan anti-Trudeau issue.

CSIS reported Chinese interference since at least 2010 when Stephen Harper was PM

Anyone trying to tie Chinese attacks against Canada to a particular party does so b/c of blind hate

That hate betrays our national security & helps foreign interests for gotcha points 🤦‍♂️#cdnpoli pic.twitter.com/CxSL7busob

— 🇨🇦 Henri A🇨🇦🇺🇦 (@HenriAGS) February 28, 2023

Anyone who suggested the Friday Han Dong leak was an act of a whistleblower needs to apologize for getting played

This is CSIS deciding they want to hurt the PM, which is fucking terrifying https://t.co/29bCk9WyiR

— Evan Scrimshaw (@EScrimshaw) March 1, 2023

A reminder of the time the RCMP contributed to the defeat of the Martin government by launching an investigation into what proved to be spurious allegations against Ralph Goodale. Without hard evidence, security forces ought to keep their noses out of electoral politics.

— David G (@accfanto) February 25, 2023

Today's Random Stuff

First, here's something I didn't know:

Reservation runway: Rising Cree designer makes New York runway debut -- ‘The future is going to be Indigenous-led’: designer Scott Wabano /via @CBCMontreal https://t.co/5ADVQ8anAR

— Treaty Commissioner (@TreatyOfficeSK) February 22, 2023

Fascinating article in The Atlantic: The Puzzling Gap Between How Old You Are and How Old You Think You Are 

 ...It’s bizarre, if you think about it. Certainly most of us don’t believe ourselves to be shorter or taller than we actually are. We don’t think of ourselves as having smaller ears or longer noses or curlier hair. Most of us also know where our bodies are in space, what physiologists call “proprioception.” Yet we seem to have an awfully rough go of locating ourselves in time.... 

 ...adults over 40 perceive themselves to be, on average, about 20 percent younger than their actual age.

 ... viewing yourself as younger is a form of optimism, rather than denialism. It says that you envision many generative years ahead of you, that you will not be written off, that your future is not one long, dreary corridor of locked doors. 

Envisioning yourself as about 15 or 20 years younger seems to start when people are in their mid-40s and 50s, according to several studies. The author explains the possible reason: 

...I’m 53 in real life but suspended at 36 in my head, and if I stop my brain from doing its usual Tilt-A-Whirl for long enough, I land on the same explanation: At 36, I knew the broad contours of my life, but hadn’t yet filled them in....I was not yet on the gray turnpike of middle age, in other words. 

... Adolescence and emerging adulthood are times dense with firsts (first kiss, first time having sex, first love, first foray into the world without your parents’ watchful gaze); they are also times when our brains, for a variety of neuro­developmental reasons, are inclined to feel things more intensely, especially the devil’s buzz of a good, foolhardy risk. 

...adults have an outsize number of memories from the ages of about 15 to 25. They called this phenomenon “the reminiscence bump.” (This is generally used to explain why we’re so responsive to the music of our adolescence—­which in my case means my iPhone is loaded with a lot more Duran Duran songs than any dignified person should admit.) 

But not everyone wants to be younger, or thinks of themselves that way. The article ends with this anecdote: 

Recently, I wrote to Margaret Atwood, asking her how old she is in her head. In the few interactions I’ve had with her, she seems quite sanguine about aging. Her reply: 

 At 53 you worry about being old compared to younger people. At 83 you enjoy the moment, and time travel here and there in the past 8 decades. You don’t fret about seeming old, because hey, you really are old! You and your friends make Old jokes. You have more fun than at 53, in some ways. Wait, you’ll see! :) 

Today's News: Ukraine Strong

A year ago, Russia launched its unprovoked invasion of Ukraine. 

A year later, Ukraine still stands. 

There is lots of commentary today about how Ukraine did this -- Zelenskyy's brilliant leadership, the indominable spirt of Ukraine's people, the ineptitude and corruption of the Russian military, the unwavering and effective financial and military support from Biden, NATO, the EU, Poland, England, and Canada.

On February 24, millions of us made a choice. Not a white flag, but the blue and yellow one. Not fleeing, but facing. Resisting & fighting.
It was a year of pain, sorrow, faith, and unity. And this year, we remained invincible. We know that 2023 will be the year of our victory! pic.twitter.com/oInWvssjOI

— Володимир Зеленський (@ZelenskyyUa) February 24, 2023

David Rothkoph has made a list of what has been learned from this war so far: 

...- While Ukraine has pleaded for fighter jets for a year, unmanned aircraft have stolen the show.... 

- “No Time for Sergeants” was once a TV hit in America. It has been a flop for the Russian army....

- Speaking of time, it’s time for traditional navies to realize their time will soon be up.... 

Poland is the new Germany. (And Estonia is the new France.)... 

- Vladimir Putin may be a madman, but at least he has the common sense not to want to be obliterated in a nuclear war with NATO.... 

- Speaking of Putin, stick a fork in him. He may not be quite done yet, but he will be soon… and besides if anyone deserves to have a fork stuck in him, it’s Putin.... 

- ...Ukraine’s masterful use of social media has played a major role in shaping global public opinion about the war... 

- Ukraine is already in the EU and NATO whether you (or Russia or Turkey) like it or not.... 

- With friends like Turkey, Israel, the global South and Elon Musk, who needs enemies?... 

- And the most important lesson of all is, as it will be for the remainder of this century, everything is always about China....

Markos describes how Ukraine is winning the war of logistics:

... the prospects of a Ukrainian winter offensive, once widely anticipated, are pretty much nil. There’s no reason to waste lives and material when heavy Western armor is on its way, while the U.S. drills Ukrainian commanders on combined arms operations in Germany’s training fields. 

Ukraine has gotten this far because it has always worked to undermine Russia’s logistics. It’s why they are screaming for longer-range rockets, to hit Russian ammo depots further behind enemy lines and force those supplies even further back. Ukraine’s success in shrinking the active front line is also its great challenge, as Russia squeezes more men into a smaller space. 

 But Ukraine won't win by killing 300,000 Russians. It will do so by cutting off their food and ammunition. Russia lost the war because of logistics, and Ukraine will win it for the same reason. 

Also at Daily Kos, check out Mark Sumner's useful month-by-month summary of the war's major events.