Russia sucks at logistics, and yet they’re trying to keep a dozen lines of attack operational. Yeah, no wonder they’ve mostly grinded to a halt. Let’s zoom in on that Kyiv and Kharkiv/Sumi axes:
See that long tendril from Sumi to Kyiv? That exists because Belorussia is north of Kyiv, Sumi is Russian border. It’s easier for Russia to get its supplies into the Kyiv area through Sumi than it is through yet another country. Yet despite being just kilometers from the border, Russia has been unable to take it. And that means that long tendril is 334 kms long (~210 miles), none of it secure, all ripe pickings for Ukrainian territorial defense forces—locals with guns and, increasingly, anti-tank missiles.....A regiment is around 600 soldiers, and [Russia has] shown no ability to mass larger groups for major assaults. One POW was complaining that his unit took more casualties from their own artillery than Ukrainians. Air cover is severely limited, likely for the same reason. Russian communication gear is literally commercial walkie talkies. Their $30 million advanced fighters have Samsung GPS units fixed to their windows. They can’t communicate, they can’t coordinate. This is the sort of thing western militaries practice time and time and time again. It’s expensive! It’s complicated! But our commanders don’t take the money and spend it on Italian villas and vodkas instead.Now ponder how Russia is expecting to take Kharkiv (pop. 1.4 million, pre-war of course), Sumy (pop. 265,000), Kyiv (pop. 2.9 million), Odesa (pop. 993,000), Mykolaiv (pop. 486,000) and Chernihiv (pop. 285,000) if they can’t even pull together 1,000 troops for an assault. No wonder they’ve settled on trying to terrorize civilians into compliance!
We are now on day nineteen of the Russian invasion of Ukraine, and it remains in something of a holding pattern. Russian airstrikes are ramping up, and no, NATO will still not implement a no-fly zone because it will mean shooting down Russian targets, blowing up air defences on Russian soil, and dragging us into a shooting war with a nuclear power while at the same time not doing anything about ground-based shelling or missile-strikes.While sanctions continue to ramp up, the IMF is warning of a massive recession in Russia, which could have bigger international ramifications.
Some tweets from today's US Defense Dept briefing:19/25 Plan C might be described as: hold current gains, long range firepower on cities, foreign fighters as cannon fodder, destroy as much infrastructure and manufacturing capacity as possible, expand the war to the west to deter foreign volunteers & aid providers. pic.twitter.com/w6BZXH4qr8
— Major General (just retired!) Mick Ryan (@WarintheFuture) March 14, 2022
Pentagon still sees no indications of the Russians sending in military reinforcements from elsewhere in Russia, the senior U.S. defense official said.
— Dan Lamothe (@DanLamothe) March 14, 2022
And Russia has no reserves left near the Ukraine borders:Pentagon still sees no indications of the Russians sending in military reinforcements from elsewhere in Russia, the senior U.S. defense official said.
— Dan Lamothe (@DanLamothe) March 14, 2022
Steven Pifer in Bulletin of The Atomic Scientists has an interesting article about the "tacit" rules that the West and Russia have agreed on so far, to avoid crossing "red lines" so that the Russia Ukraine War will not escalate into World War Three.Pentagon still sees no indications of Belarus sending in forces to join the fight, senior U.S. defense official says.
— Dan Lamothe (@DanLamothe) March 14, 2022
First, President Biden, NATO Secretary General Stoltenberg, and NATO member-state leaders have said that, while they will defend NATO territory, NATO forces will not take on Russian forces to defend Ukraine. ....It explains NATO’s decision not to establish a no-fly zone over Ukraine....Second, US and NATO intelligence-sharing with Ukraine appears acceptable under the rules....they have not challenged US, British, and NATO aircraft conducting intelligence and air surveillance missions to look at what the Russian military is doing in, near, and over Ukraine. .... once the Russian military launched its invasion. US and British aircraft no longer fly in Ukrainian air space and appear to take more care regarding flights over the Black Sea.Third, the rules permit at least some Western arms shipments to Ukraine. In the weeks before and since Russian forces attacked, the United States, NATO member-states, and others have provided a stream of defense assistance to Ukraine,...the Russians do not like the arms shipments, though they have not acted to interdict them. ...[regarding the offer of Migs from Poland] The European Union, Polish, and US officials aired too much of the Mig-29 issue in public ... The fighters should have just been given to the Ukrainian air force with no public discussion, denying Moscow the opportunity to try to impose a limit on the arms provision rule....Fourth, economic and other sanctions appear acceptable, if disliked, within the tacit rules, even if they went well beyond what the Kremlin might have anticipated. ...Moscow thus far has not wielded what many see as its major counter-sanction: an embargo of oil and gas sales to Europe, which would cause an energy crisis there....
These war crimes will not be forgotten or forgiven.“He probably knows that his mama is dead,” Stanislav said of his seven-year-old son. “But he still keeps calling her.”
— Julia Ioffe (@juliaioffe) March 15, 2022
Unpopular opinion: The day Putin accepts a ceasefire in 🇺🇦 will be the worst day in Ukrainian history.
The entire world will pressure Kyiv (@Zele— Julian Röpcke🇺🇦 (@JulianRoepcke) March 12, 2022nskyyUa) to accept the offer, he must/will, and whatever is under Russian control at this moment will never be given back to Ukraine. pic.twitter.com/zDEzyPMFR3— Julian Röpcke🇺🇦 (@JulianRoepcke) March 12, 2022
One last remark: There is a tiny chance, Putin is insane enough to keep fighting and try conquering all of eastern, southern and central Ukraine.
— Julian Röpcke🇺🇦 (@JulianRoepcke) March 12, 2022
In this case, the military and political outcome is entirely unpredictable – for Ukraine, Russia and the world.
Yes, I can understand why Ukraine would not want to give away its territory, especially those provinces that would give Russia a direct access to Crimea and the Black Sea - Putin can strut and call that a victory, though its a far cry from what he actually wanted.I estimate the deal will include a withdrawal of Russian forces from Kyiv, Sumy, Mykolaiv, Chernihiv and Kharkiv regions, so Zelensky can present himself as the savior of 🇺🇦 statehood & identity.
— Julian Röpcke🇺🇦 (@JulianRoepcke) March 13, 2022
In return, occupied Luhansk, Donetsk, Zaporozhia, Crimea and Kherson will go to 🇷🇺. pic.twitter.com/S7F1JGsxaf
Latest Defence Intelligence update on the situation in Ukraine - 15 March 2022
— Ministry of Defence 🇬🇧 (@DefenceHQ) March 15, 2022
Find out more about the UK government's response: https://t.co/aNa33WPBRi
🇺🇦 #StandWithUkraine 🇺🇦 pic.twitter.com/lrw4wxDvxL
I think - I hope! - that this experience will make everyone put a little more thought and consideration into the quality of the politicians they are electing in the future. Because it matters!Born in 1967. I wish it was strange but it’s not. It’s like a childhood disease you thought was long in remission flaring up again. https://t.co/Vvi43wWsPT
— STEVE HUFF (@SteveHuff) March 14, 2022
No comments:
Post a Comment