Thursday, June 19, 2025

War between America and Iran? "Avoid history at all costs. History is too big, too abstract, too dangerous."


They're doing it again.
It sounds like Trump is going to get the United States involved in another damn war in the Middle East.
Journalist Gary Kamiya wrote this article for Salon magazine in 2003, two weeks before the US invasion of Iraq. 
It remains eerily prescient today: 
Gary Kamiya / Salon March 11, 2003 
Sleepwalking toward Baghdad 
As the sand runs out on peace, America drifts alone toward a strange and unjustified war. 
 ... we have gone from being in a political moment to a historical one.
I use the words somewhat eccentrically, to distinguish between events that are simple enough to be fully explicable ("political") and those that are too complex to be defined ("historical"). The war against Afghanistan took place in what I am calling the political realm: It had a clear, limited and achievable goal, one understood by all -- and widely supported around the world. The impending war against Iraq, on the other hand, is a historical event. It cannot be explained or defined. When it comes, it will simply exist, with the opacity of history. Its outcome is not foreseeable.
The distinction also has a moral dimension. To exist in history is to have passed beyond the pieties and slogans of the political. History is tragic: politics is not. History is glorious. It is also fatal.
The two great competing ideologies of the 20th century, fascism and communism, were both self-consciously historical movements. As Czeslaw Milosz brilliantly noted in his classic study "The Captive Mind," it was precisely the abstraction of communism, its claim to have attained the summit of morality and to have incorporated into itself all possible contradictions, that made it so meticulously horrifying. In similar fashion, fascism contained a kind of blankness at its core: the self-glorifying violence of the state simultaneously concealed and revealed the emptiness of its founding concept, the national tribe.
The lesson every government should have learned from the bloody 20th century, one written in blood across the tortured soil of old, very old Europe, is very simple: Avoid history at all costs. History is too big, too abstract, too dangerous. Avoid men with Big Ideas -- especially stupid men with Big Ideas. Take care of politics: let history take care of itself. In a word, don't play God.
George Bush is a deeply religious man, and he deeply believes in the God-given mission of the United States to shed light -- Auden's "affirming flame" -- upon the world. But as we wait for the bombs to fall, we can only pray that he does not release darkness.
(Painting is Paul Nash, Landscape from a Dream)

3 comments:

Cap said...

Wait, a genocidal maniac is leading Iran?! Netanyahu is the one under an international arrest warrant, not Khamenei.

America's entry into Israel's war of choice with Iran is inevitable because Israel's missile defense is an Iron Sieve. Iran's missiles have hit the HQs of Mossad and Aman (military intelligence), as well as a critical oil refinery in Haifa. This is not being reported in the MSM, which is going along with the blanket military censorship Netanyahu imposed. The media is careful to say "Iran claims" before such reports, but the facts themselves are easily verified.

America will stumble into this led by a demented, corrupt felon, an incompetent, alcoholic defense secretary, and a chairman of the joint chiefs of staff hired for his nickname. It's opsec will be compromised by a defense secretary who communicates war plans over Signal, with his wife on the group chat. It will go to war without clear objectives with a country the size of France, Germany and Italy combined, with a larger population, and with soldiers who showed fanatical zeal in the Iran-Iraq war. Time to lay in a big stock of popcorn to watch the sun set on the American empire.

Cathie from Canada said...

Cap, I fear you are right! It is going to be awful and I can't imagine how it will end.

Purple library guy said...

All this so Netanyahu can continue avoiding the corruption charges in Israel that he'll be back in court facing as soon as the situation normalizes enough for his political opponents to get together and throw him out of office.